Toilet Keeps Running? Why It Happens and How We Fix It in the Illawarra
When a toilet keeps running, water is usually leaking past a worn outlet valve seal inside the cistern, or the inlet valve is not shutting off when the cistern is full. At Plumbing Creations, a Kiama based licensed plumber, we fix running toilets across Wollongong, Shellharbour and Kiama, and most of these repairs are done in under an hour.
That constant trickle is easy to ignore, but it is water you are paying for every hour of the day. Here is what causes a running toilet, how to tell which part has failed, and when it makes sense to repair the cistern or replace the toilet.
Prefer to listen? Hear this as a podcast episode on The Service Hub.
Why does my toilet keep running after I flush?
Almost every running toilet comes down to the parts inside the cistern. A modern cistern has three key parts:
- The inlet valve, also called the fill valve, which refills the cistern after each flush and should shut off when the water reaches the right level.
- The outlet valve, also called the flush valve, which has a rubber seal that lifts to release water into the bowl and then seals again.
- The button mechanism, which connects the push button to the outlet valve.
When the rubber seal on the outlet valve wears out, water keeps slipping past it into the bowl. The inlet valve then keeps topping the cistern up, so the toilet never stops running. A faulty inlet valve or a float set too high can do the same thing by letting the cistern overfill.
How can I tell which part has failed?
You can often get a good idea before you call us. Lift the cistern lid carefully and watch what happens after a flush.
- Water keeps trickling into the bowl long after the flush, and you may see a small ripple in the bowl. This usually points to a worn outlet valve seal.
- The water level keeps rising until it spills into the overflow. This usually points to the inlet valve not shutting off, or the float being set too high.
- The cistern refills by itself every so often with no one using it. This is often a slow leak past the outlet seal.
- The button sticks or does not return after you press it. The button mechanism or its linkage may be holding the valve open.
Please do not force any parts. Old plastic components can crack, and a cracked inlet valve can turn a small leak into a big one.
Is a running toilet worth fixing straight away?
Yes. A running toilet wastes water around the clock and shows up on your water bill. It also tends to get worse, not better, as the seal keeps wearing.
The good news is that this is one of the most common plumbing jobs in Illawarra homes, and it is usually a quick repair rather than a big one. On our toilet flushing repairs page you can see the full range of flush and cistern work we do.
What about a weak flush or a dual flush that has stopped working?
Running is not the only cistern fault we see. Two others often turn up on the same visit.
Weak or incomplete flush
If you need to flush twice, the cause is usually a low water level in the cistern from a slow inlet valve, an outlet valve that only opens part way, or blocked rim jets where calcium build up restricts the small holes under the rim.
Dual flush problems
Dual flush toilets have an extra failure point. The half flush mechanism can separate from the full flush, so both buttons give a full flush. Buttons can also stick and fail to return.
My toilet keeps running, how do you fix it?
We start by finding which part has actually failed, then repair or replace only what is needed. Depending on what we find, the fix might be:
- Replacing the outlet valve seal so it seals properly again and stops the trickle into the bowl.
- Replacing or adjusting the inlet valve so the cistern fills to the right level and shuts off.
- Repairing the button mechanism or the cable or linkage that connects it to the outlet valve.
- A full cistern overhaul, replacing the inlet valve, the outlet valve and the button mechanism together, which makes the cistern work like new.
We carry common parts on the van and work on all brands, so most running toilets can be fixed the same day.
Should I repair my toilet or replace it?
Most of the time, repair is the smart choice. A running toilet is usually one worn part, not a worn out toilet.
Replacement starts to make more sense when the toilet is around 20 years old or more, needs repairs several times a year, has visible cracks in the porcelain, or is an old single flush model. If you do replace it, an upgrade to a modern dual flush toilet with a 4 star WELS rating can cut the water your toilet uses considerably. We will give you honest advice on which option is the better investment, and our toilet repairs page covers the other toilet problems we fix.
What affects the price of a running toilet repair?
We give you a fixed price before we start work, so you are never guessing. The things that change the price include:
- Which part has failed, a single seal or valve versus the whole cistern mechanism
- The brand and age of the cistern and how easy parts are to match
- Whether the cistern is exposed or concealed in the wall
- Whether there is a second problem, such as a leak at the base or a blockage
- Whether you choose to repair the cistern or replace the toilet
Frequently asked questions
How long does it take to fix a running toilet?
Most running toilet repairs take 30 to 60 minutes once we are on site, and same day repairs are often available.
Can a running toilet increase my water bill?
Yes. Water running past a worn seal flows all day and night, so even a slow trickle adds up over a billing period.
Can I keep using a toilet that keeps running?
Usually yes, it is not an emergency. If you want to stop the waste until we arrive, you can turn off the small stop tap on the water line to the cistern and turn it back on when you need to flush.
Do you fix all toilet brands?
Yes. We repair all brands and models and carry common parts on the van.
Book a running toilet repair
If your toilet keeps running, flushes weakly or refills on its own, call Plumbing Creations on 0411 360 263. We are a licensed plumber based in Kiama, servicing Wollongong, Shellharbour, Kiama and the wider Illawarra, Monday to Thursday 7am to 7pm and Friday to Saturday 7am to 5pm.
Plumbing Creations
Kiama NSW
0411 360 263
Find us on Google Maps